Skip to content

Donor Stewardship Plan: Matrix, Retention Rates and a 90-Day Start

Most first-time donors do not come back. In the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's full-year 2025 data, 18.9% of first-time donors gave again the next year, while 59.3% of repeat donors did. That gap is the whole argument for stewardship: the work you do after a gift decides whether there is a next one. This guide gives you a plan that fits on one page — a retention baseline, a matrix of four touches per donor group and a first-90-days sequence for new donors.

What donor stewardship is — and what it is not

Stewardship covers everything between one gift and the next: thanking the donor, showing what the money did, recognizing them and keeping them close to the work. Cultivation happens before the first gift; stewardship happens after it and earns the next one.

Kathleen Kelly's model, which placed stewardship inside the public relations process, names four parts:

  • Reciprocity — you show gratitude for the gift.
  • Responsibility — you spend the money the way you said you would.
  • Reporting — you tell the donor what happened.
  • Relationship nurturing — you keep the donor involved between asks.

A donor stewardship plan is simply the written version: which donors get which touches, when, and who sends them. For most nonprofits it is one page, not a binder.

Start with your retention baseline

The Fundraising Effectiveness Project (FEP), run by the AFP Foundation for Philanthropy and GivingTuesday with data from donor databases including Bloomerang, Neon One and DonorPerfect, is the closest thing the sector has to a national benchmark. Its Q4 2025 report covers the full year. The table below is the captured 2025 reference; treat it as a dated benchmark and check current reports before you set targets.

[REFERENCE TABLE: retention-by-donor-type — deliver every original row and cell exactly]

The pattern matters more than any single number. Each additional gift makes the next one far more likely: donors who gave once returned 31.9% of the time, while donors who gave seven or more times returned 87.4% of the time. The FEP describes turning a first gift into a second as the donor pipeline's most consequential unsolved problem, and the first-time rate did not move between 2024 and 2025.

Why the "average" retention rate you read online keeps changing

Published averages range from roughly 26% to 55%, and they can all be real because they measure different things:

  • Full year vs. year to date. A mid-year FEP report showing 26.4% covers only January to June; donors still have half a year to give.
  • Online only. M+R Benchmarks 2026 found 48% of online one-time donors gave online again, but that figure does not see checks or event gifts.
  • One vendor's customers. Some donor database companies publish the average for their own clients — useful, but not the sector.
  • Monthly donors. These are measured month by month; M+R found 71% of monthly donors were still giving after a year.

So compare like with like. Use full-year FEP numbers for your whole file and track first-time and repeat donors as two separate lines. Treat the national figures as a starting reference, not a verdict on your program: what actually tells you whether the plan is working is whether your own rate climbs above where it sat a year ago.

Calculate your retention rate in two minutes

To get your overall rate, divide the number of last year's donors who gave again this year by the total number of people who gave last year, then multiply by 100.

If 500 people gave last year and 215 gave again, that is 215 ÷ 500 × 100 = 43%. Then run the same math twice more, because one number hides the problem:

  • First-time donor retention — take last year's first-time donors and count how many gave again.
  • Repeat donor retention — do the same for everyone else from last year.

Three rules keep the numbers honest: count people, not gifts; use the same 12 months in both years; count a household once.

The calculator below compares each rate with the FEP's 2025 averages. Enter unique donors for the same 12 months in both years.

[FORM CONTROLS: form-controls-contract — deliver every original input, label and default value exactly]

A worked example using the captured defaults: 500 donors last year, 215 retained, 200 of them first-time with 38 retained, and a $150 average yearly gift. That produces 43.0% overall (0.3 points below the 43.3% average), 19.0% for first-time donors (0.1 points above 18.9%) and 59.0% for repeat donors (0.3 points below 59.3%). The calculator also reports that 285 of last year's 500 donors have not given again — about $42,750 a year at that average gift. Lifting the first-time rate by 10 points would keep 20 more donors, about $3,000 a year. That group is where a stewardship plan pays back first.

Averages: the FEP's Q4 2025 report, full-year 2025 data from 15,102 nonprofits.

Why a thank-you alone will not keep donors

Thank donors fast — the receipt is the first touch they get from you. In the US, a donor giving $250 or more needs a written acknowledgment to claim the deduction, and IRS rules also ask for a disclosure on any gift over $75 where the donor received something in return, such as a gala ticket.

But the thank-you is manners, not the plan. Anya Samek and Chuck Longfield tested this at scale: they randomly selected 500,000 new donors at public TV stations and a national nonprofit and thanked half of them with a phone call. Fundraising professionals predicted the calls would raise retention by about 80%. The calls made no measurable difference.

That does not mean stop calling. It means a call cannot carry the plan alone. The FEP's advice for first-year donors points at what is missing: show the impact clearly and promptly after the first gift. A receipt says thank you; a story from the program tells the donor their money landed somewhere real.

Build the plan in six steps

You can do this in an afternoon with last year's donor list and a spreadsheet.

  1. Pull last year's numbers. Work out overall, first-time and repeat retention with the calculator, so you have a baseline.
  2. Split donors into groups. Use first-time, repeat, monthly, mid-level and major, and lapsed donors.
  3. Assign four touches to each group. Every group gets thanked, shown what the gift accomplished, recognized in some way, and asked a single question.
  4. Map the touches onto a calendar. Lay out the new-donor 90-day sequence first, then schedule the remaining months of the year around it.
  5. Gather stories ahead of schedule. Ask each program for a handful of stories and invite donors to explain why they give, so nothing is scrambled together at send time.
  6. Name an owner for every row and review quarterly. Check the plan against your retention rates and cut what nobody sends.

Split donors by how they give, not only by how much

Gift size still matters for major donors, but across most of your file, giving tenure carries more signal than gift amount. A $50 donor in their fifth year needs a different note than a $50 donor in their first week. Your donor database can split them by first gift date and number of gifts.

The donor stewardship matrix: four touches per group

A donor stewardship matrix is a grid — donor groups down the side, touches across. Keep it to four touches per group to start; add more once these run on time.

[REFERENCE TABLE: donor-stewardship-matrix — deliver every original row and cell exactly]

Notice the second touch in every row: it is a story or a result, not another ask. Members and volunteers who also give deserve a row of their own; recognition for them might take the form of a member spotlight or a volunteer story published on your site.

Run the cycle all year, not once a year

The donor stewardship cycle is simple: thank, show, recognize, listen, then ask again. The ask comes last, and it should sound like the donor's own reason for giving — which is only possible if the listening step happened.

The first 90 days decide whether a first-time donor gives again

If you fix only one part of the plan, fix this one. It is the group with the 18.9% rate, and the one the FEP says the sector has not cracked.

  • Within 48 hours. Send the receipt and a short personal thank-you. Name the program they gave to.
  • Week 2. Send a welcome note with one story from that program, in the words of someone it helped.
  • Day 45. Send a "here's what your gift did" update — a person, a number and a photo, not a newsletter.
  • Day 60. Ask one question: "What made you give?" The answer tells you what to say next time.
  • Day 90. Invite them in: a tour, a volunteer shift, a short field video or an event.

At month 6, return to their program with another update. When the renewal ask comes around month 10 or 11, frame it around the answer they gave on day 60. In many nonprofits that ask lands in the year-end appeal, so lead with a story from the program they supported. Monthly donors need a version of this too — M+R found 10% of new monthly donors stop within two months, so their welcome matters even more.

Three examples of showing donors what their gift did

The best stewardship examples do not look like fundraising. They look like proof.

DonorsChoose sends a thank-you package from the classroom. Teachers ask the public to fund classroom projects, and when a project is funded the teacher owes donors a package. Per the DonorsChoose help center, it includes an impact letter from the teacher, 2 to 10 photos of students using the materials and, for some projects, handwritten student thank-yous. *Lesson:* let the thank-you double as the impact report. A picture of what the gift actually paid for says more than a generic "your support makes a difference" sentence.

charity: water gives every finished project its own page. The page for Bihanga II in Uganda shows map coordinates, photos of the tap stand, the local partner and the number of people served — 22. Each fundraising team's page lists the projects its money funded. *Lesson:* give each donor's money a place they can picture. You do not need GPS; a program page with real faces and one honest number does the job.

WKAR asks supporters to share their own story. The public radio and TV station at Michigan State University runs a Share Your WKAR Story page where supporters send text, record video or audio, or leave a voice message. WKAR uses those stories to show decision makers how much the community values the station. *Lesson:* donors' reasons for giving are stewardship too. Asking why they give makes them feel heard, and sharing the answers with permission lets the next donor hear from someone like them.

A "why I give" wall makes stewardship visible

Two kinds of stories do different jobs. Program stories demonstrate what a gift accomplished, so place one on the donation page, the thank-you page and in the day 45 update. Donor stories explain why people give; a "why I give" wall written by donors answers the question every new donor has: who else gives here, and why?

A practical setup:

  • One collection page per program. Prompt with "What changed for you?" and accept answers as text or video.
  • One "why I give" form for donors. Three questions work well: what prompted your first gift, what keeps you giving, and what would you tell a friend? A short story drive before Giving Tuesday fills it fast.
  • A permission checkbox on every form. Write the line in your own words so donors know exactly how their story will be used.
  • A wall per program. Embed it on the program and donation pages, or share the hosted wall link in your day 45 email. Nobody needs to touch the website.

AAHA, the American Animal Hospital Association, runs this setup for its accredited hospitals, with the form and the wall on the same page. New stories wait for team approval, or you can let them go live on their own; either way the page keeps filling while you get on with the rest of the plan.

Ask before you name any donor. Some want public thanks; others give quietly and want it to stay that way. Record each donor's recognition preference in your database. If a donor prefers anonymity, leave their story off the wall and thank them in private.

15 low-cost donor stewardship ideas

You do not need a gala budget for donor appreciation. Most of these take under an hour.

For the thank-you

  1. Send a 30-second thank-you video from someone the program helped, not only from the director.
  2. Ask a board member to write five handwritten notes a month to first-time donors.
  3. Put the program name in every receipt — "your gift to the reading program," not "your donation."
  4. Thank monthly donors on their one-year anniversary with what 12 gifts added up to.
  5. Send a thank-you text or email on the day the money gets used, such as the day the van is purchased.

To show the impact

  1. Send one photo with one sentence: "This is the room your gift painted."
  2. Share a mid-year update that is only good news and contains no ask.
  3. Put a wall of program stories on the donation page so donors see the work both before and after they give.
  4. Make a short impact report per program instead of one report for everyone.
  5. Write a "where your money went" breakdown with three lines and real numbers.

For recognition, with permission

  1. Feature a "why I give" story in each newsletter.
  2. Post donor stories on social media, naming the donor only if they have said yes.
  3. Start a giving circle or society for donors who give three years in a row, named after something in your work.
  4. Host a small behind-the-scenes tour — often the best appreciation event on a small budget.
  5. Send a donor survey once a year and share what you changed because of it.

Donor survey questions that reveal why people give — and why they stopped

A short donor survey is the "listen" touch in your matrix. Keep it under five questions or people stop halfway.

For active donors

  1. What prompted your very first gift to us?
  2. What keeps you giving today?
  3. Which of our programs matters most to you?
  4. How often would you like to hear from us, and through which channels?
  5. How would you describe us to a friend who asked?

Question 5 is the one to watch. With permission, the best answers can go on your "why I give" wall.

For lapsed donors — send to people who gave two years ago and have not given since:

  1. What first made you give to us?
  2. What changed?
  3. Is there anything we could have done better?

Some donors stop for reasons you cannot fix, like money or a move. You will also hear about the ones you can fix, like never hearing back after the gift.

Which rate should you fix first? A quick decision checklist

Use your three calculator outputs to choose where the plan starts:

  • First-time rate weakest? Run the 90-day sequence first and assign an owner to each of the five touches. This is the highest-leverage fix for most files.
  • Repeat rate weakest? Your existing donors are drifting. Add the quarterly program story and the annual survey before adding any new ask.
  • Overall rate weakest but both segments near average? Check your counting rules first — gifts instead of people, mismatched 12-month windows or double-counted households can distort the baseline.
  • All three above the 2025 averages? Protect what works: keep the calendar, keep the owners, and compare this year against your own last-year number rather than the national figure.

Whatever you choose, write the baseline down before you start. Without it you cannot tell whether the plan is working.

Donor retention by donor type, full-year 2025
Donor groupGave again the next year
All donors43.3% (FEP, 2025)
First-time donors18.9% (FEP, 2025)
Repeat donors59.3% (FEP, 2025)
Gave once last year31.9% (FEP, 2025)
Gave 7+ times last year87.4% (FEP, 2025)
New online donors24% (M+R, 2025)
Monthly donors71% still giving after 12 months (M+R)

Dated reference: FEP Q4 2025 full-year data; M+R figures are online-only and monthly-donor measures. Check current reports before setting targets.

Donor stewardship matrix: four touches per donor group
Donor groupThank, show, recognize, listen
First-time donorsThank in 48 hours. Program story in week 2. What your gift did at day 45. Ask why they gave at day 60.
Repeat donorsThank with their giving history. A story from their program every quarter. A "why I give" feature, with permission. A yearly survey.
Monthly donorsWelcome in week 1. What 12 gifts added up to at year one. An anniversary note. Ask how they'd like to hear from you.
Mid-level and major donorsA personal call or note. A report on their program. A tour or a field visit. A real conversation about what's next.
Lapsed donorsThank them for past support. One story from the program they funded. Invite them back without guilt. A 3-question survey.

Start with four touches per group; add more only once these run on time.

Frequently asked questions

What should a donor stewardship plan include?

Your donor groups, the touches each group gets, when each touch happens and who sends it. Add your current retention rates so you can tell whether the plan is working.

What are the four pillars of donor stewardship?

Kathleen Kelly's model names reciprocity, responsibility, reporting and relationship nurturing. In plain terms: thank donors, use their money as promised, tell them what happened and keep them involved.

What is the average donor retention rate?

In the FEP's full-year 2025 data, the average was 43.3%. First-time donors were retained at 18.9% and repeat donors at 59.3%. These are dated benchmarks; check the latest report for current figures.

How often should you contact donors?

Reach a first-time donor roughly five times during their first 90 days, and keep every one of those touches free of a fresh request for money. From then on, plan on about one story or update each month, with a handful of asks spread across the year.

What is the difference between cultivation and stewardship?

Cultivation happens before the first gift. Stewardship happens after it — thanking, reporting, recognizing and listening — and it is what earns the next gift.