Best Nonprofit Websites: 12 Examples Scored on Their Stories
Most roundups judge a nonprofit homepage by its photography, mission statement and donation button. That misses the page visitors use to verify impact: the stories page. A dated check on 9 November 2026 looked at 110 expert-recommended nonprofit sites. Of the 109 that still loaded, only 34 linked to a stories page from the homepage and only 6 sorted stories by program. The 12 examples below are scored on what a visitor can actually see.
What separates strong nonprofit websites
A strong nonprofit site does three things: it identifies who it helps, demonstrates that help and makes giving straightforward. Polished design is now common, so credible proof is the differentiator. Homepage storytelling can create curiosity, but the stories page is where a donor, board member or prospective volunteer checks whether the claims hold up.
Use this five-point scorecard, one point per check:
- The stories page is reachable from the main menu or homepage in one click.
- Stories are organised by program, campaign or another meaningful group.
- Each story names a real person and describes a concrete change.
- At least one story is presented as video.
- The page invites the next person to share a story.
No example reached 5/5. The shared gap was video: none of the 12 stories pages had a video story. That is an opportunity for a small communications team. Named people, a few videos and a section per program will put a site ahead of most highly praised peers, and the resulting page gives grant reports, newsletters and board packs a single reusable link.
12 examples scored on their stories
American Lung Association — 4/5. Copy this: a story page for each campaign. Its homepage links directly to Shared Stories, which held more than 2,700 stories across 154 pages at the time of the check. Cards show a first name, last initial and state. A Share Your Story button explains how the name will appear. The Healthy Air campaign goes further with its own submission page and story collection. Missing: video, faces on many cards, and program filtering on the main page.
Farm Africa — 3/5. Copy this: filtering by program. Its stories can be filtered by country, focus area and year, with focus areas shown on each card. One example follows Lotty, a 61-year-old farmer in Kongwa District, Tanzania, who trained in agroforestry and now runs a tree nursery selling thousands of seedlings. Missing: video and a way for farmers or partners to submit their own story.
Girl Scouts — 3/5. Copy this: a dedicated door for the Gold Award. The Our Stories page separates Girl Scout Stories, Gold Award Stories and Alum Stories before mixed rows such as World Changers. Missing: video and a submission form for girls, parents or alums.
National Park Foundation — 3/5. Copy this: donor stories by giving society. Impact Stories and Donor Stories are kept separate, and donor cards name the giving society. Specific headlines such as 300+ Park Trips and Counting tell the story before a click. Missing: video and an invitation for other donors to contribute.
Make-A-Wish — 3/5. Copy this: wish kids, donors and volunteers on one page. Our Stories begins with wish kids, then moves to donor and volunteer stories. A share-your-story form exists, but the stories page does not link to it. Missing: that link, plus browsing by chapter even though chapter is collected on submissions.
Malala Fund — 3/5. Copy this: girl stories by country. Stories sit within News and Voices, with tabs for girl, partner and donor stories and a country filter. Girl stories carry writer names and topic tags. Missing: a standalone stories experience, video and a share form; press releases share the same feed.
Blood Cancer United — 3/5. Copy this: a diagnosis on every story. Cards show a first name plus a diagnosis or role, such as acute lymphoblastic leukemia or family member and caregiver. A Share your story button sits near the top. Missing: filtering by diagnosis and video.
Covenant House — 3/5. Copy this: the house named on every card. Youth, alumni, partners, volunteers and donors can share stories, and each card identifies the house that helped. A Share Your Story block appears near the bottom. Missing: filtering by house or program, and video.
The Nature Conservancy — 2/5. Copy this: a 75th-birthday story drive. The anniversary page asks, in effect, for each person's place in nature. The weakness is collection: the button led to a social post, so submissions did not appear on the organisation's own site. Missing: on-site display, program sorting and a person-led video story.
St. Jude — 2/5. Copy this: one framing number above the stories. The page opens with childhood cancer survival rising from 20% in 1962 to more than 80% today, followed by a patient slider with diagnoses. Missing: browsing by diagnosis, video and a share form.
Ronald McDonald House Charities — 2/5. Copy this: bright, consistent story cards. Thirty-four stories are divided into Family Stories, Chapter Highlights and Community of Care. Missing: sorting by core program, so a Family Room family cannot easily find similar families, plus video and a share form.
Playworks — 2/5. Copy this: role and school on every quote. Testimonials name principals, schools and cities, which helps peers trust the account. Missing: freshness. The newest testimonial dated from January 2021, with others going back to 2017, which can make a visitor wonder whether the program has changed.
What a nonprofit website should include
Plan for seven pages:
- Homepage: who you help, where you work and one donation button.
- About: mission, history, team and board.
- Programs: one page per program, covering who it is for and how to join.
- Stories: real people by program, with names, faces and video.
- Donate: a short form, monthly giving and what a gift achieves.
- Get involved: volunteering, events and a share-your-story form.
- Contact: email, phone, address, annual report and Form 990.
The stories page is the one most often skipped: in the dated check, 75 of 109 live sites had no stories page linked from the homepage.
Design practices worth adopting:
- State who you help and where in the first homepage screen.
- Keep the donation button in the same place on every page.
- Put stories in the main menu.
- Give each program its own stories, either on its own page or behind a filter.
- Name the person and the change in every story.
- Add a few video stories; a face and voice carry more weight than a paragraph.
- Invite submissions and date every story.
- Check colour contrast, add alt text to photos and ensure forms work on mobile and by keyboard.
Templates, platforms and association stories
Templates solve layout, not evidence. In the captured notes, Squarespace offered nonprofit templates and a donation block from $25/month, or $19/month billed yearly; Wix offered a free plan and nonprofit templates from $17/month billed yearly; WordPress is free software with hosting and theme costs, suited to teams working with an agency; WildApricot combined membership, dues, events and a website from $66/month for 100 contacts. These are dated captured figures, not current offers.
None of those options automatically supplies the stories. A story wall can be embedded in Squarespace, Wix or WordPress without a developer.
Association sites face an extra test: they must prove membership value to non-members. Three captured examples show the pattern. The American Animal Hospital Association asks accredited hospitals what accreditation means to their practice and what changed after accreditation, then displays answers on a member wall. The Chartered Institute of Public Relations collected 175 written and 25 video stories in two weeks for a campaign celebrating 1,000 Chartered PR Practitioners. WKAR invites listeners to submit text, video or audio. The shared move is one story link and one wall per program or campaign.
Add a stories page this week
A small team can complete the core setup in an afternoon:
- List every program and create a separate story link for each.
- Ask three change-focused questions: what life was like before joining, what changed and when it was first noticed, and what the person would tell someone considering joining.
- Enable video submission and add a consent checkbox explaining where the story will appear. Keep anonymous submissions off the public wall.
- Approve selected stories, embed each program's wall on its program page and link a combined stories page from the main menu.
- Send the relevant program link when a cohort graduates, a campaign closes or another milestone is reached.
The timing matters. The week a cycle ends is when the experience is freshest and the participant is most likely to respond. Put the link in that week's email, newsletter or year-end appeal.
Start with one program, one link and one wall. That alone fixes the most common gap in the 12 examples: stories exist somewhere, but visitors cannot find the ones relevant to them.
| Page | What it needs |
|---|---|
| Homepage | Who you help, where, and 1 donate button |
| About | Mission, history, team and board |
| Programs | A page per program: who it's for and how to join |
| Stories | Real people per program, with names, faces and video |
| Donate | A short form, monthly giving and what a gift does |
| Get involved | Volunteer, events and a share-your-story form |
| Contact | Email, phone, address, annual report and Form 990 |
Use as a completeness checklist; adapt the labels to your programs.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best nonprofit websites for inspiration?
For story-led inspiration, study the American Lung Association for a campaign-specific stories page, Farm Africa for filtering by program, and Girl Scouts for a dedicated Gold Award entry point.
What is the best website platform for nonprofits?
Squarespace and Wix are presented as the simplest options for a small team. WordPress offers more control when agency support is available, while WildApricot is aimed at membership associations that also need dues and events.
How much does a nonprofit website cost?
In the captured pricing notes, Wix started at $17/month billed yearly and Squarespace at $25/month billed monthly. WildApricot started at $66/month for 100 contacts. Custom agency builds are quoted per project. Treat these as dated captured figures, not current offers.
How often should a nonprofit update its website?
Add stories whenever a program cycle ends and review the wider site once a year. Freshness matters: one example had a story dated the day it was checked, while another's newest testimonial dated from January 2021.
| Website | Stories score | What to copy |
|---|---|---|
| American Lung Association | 4/5 | A story page per campaign |
| Farm Africa | 3/5 | Filter stories by program |
| Girl Scouts | 3/5 | A door for the Gold Award |
| National Park Foundation | 3/5 | Donor stories, by giving society |
| Make-A-Wish | 3/5 | Kids, donors and volunteers |
| Malala Fund | 3/5 | Girl stories by country |
| Blood Cancer United | 3/5 | A diagnosis on every story |
| Covenant House | 3/5 | The house named on every card |
| The Nature Conservancy | 2/5 | A 75th-birthday story drive |
| St. Jude | 2/5 | 1 number above the stories |
| Ronald McDonald House Charities | 2/5 | Bright, consistent story cards |
| Playworks | 2/5 | Role and school on every quote |
Scores are dated captured evidence from 9 November 2026 and reflect the five checks described on this page.