Testimonial Software for Recruiting Firms: 6 Tools Compared
Recruiting firms sell to two audiences at once. Hiring managers need evidence that similar roles were filled quickly and well, while candidates need evidence that they will be prepared and kept informed. A single mixed page rarely serves either reader. This comparison looks at six tools through that split, plus timing, desk-level organisation, anonymous credit, and cost for a 10-recruiter firm.
How the tools were judged
Use five checks. First, keep audiences separate: client proof belongs on employer pages and candidate proof on jobs or careers pages, because a quote about interview preparation does not reassure a hiring manager and a quote about time-to-hire does not reassure a candidate. Second, time the ask to existing milestones such as offer acceptance, start date, and 30, 60 and 90-day check-ins; some tools trigger from an ATS stage change, others supply a link for your placement email. Third, give each desk or vertical its own wall so finance, IT and healthcare visitors see relevant proof rather than a recruiter-by-recruiter feed. Fourth, plan anonymous credit: a role and employer type can keep proof credible when names cannot be used, and written permission should cover either format. Fifth, check how price scales, since per-recruiter pricing grows with headcount while wall, form or response pricing may not.
Separate client and candidate walls with video
A first-party collection tool with separate walls and links per audience, text and video capture in the browser, approval before publishing, and editable credit lines. It does not connect to an ATS or send reminders, so the link must be pasted into placement emails, and it does not create public recruiter profiles. Best fit: firms prioritising owned client and candidate walls on a flat monthly bill. See owner inputs for plan and pricing confirmation.
Great Recruiters: recruiter-level reviews from the ATS
Built for staffing firms on Bullhorn, Avionté, LaborEdge and Tracker. Reviews attach to individual recruiters, each of whom gets a public profile with ratings and recommend scores, plus shareable testimonial cards and team dashboards. Website widgets, public profiles and beta video start on Growth; custom questions, placement and end-client reviews and exports require Pro. Best fit: firms where each recruiter's public record is the brand. Limitation: proof is organised around recruiters rather than desks or clients.
ClearlyRated: measured satisfaction that can become testimonials
A satisfaction survey programme connecting to Bullhorn and Salesforce. Client and talent surveys run at set milestones, happy respondents are invited to add a testimonial, and results appear first on a directory profile with client and talent ratings side by side. Export for your site and LinkedIn is available, and strong survey results can support a Best of Staffing award. Pricing is quote-only, yearly, tiered by employee count; surveying both audiences requires at least the middle tier, and automatic ATS or CRM sync sits on the top tier. Best fit: mid-size firms wanting measured satisfaction and an award. Limitation: testimonials are a by-product of the survey programme and no price is visible before a sales call.
TopRec by Refari: feedback at interview and placement stages
Feedback tool from a recruitment website provider, connecting to JobAdder, Seven20, RecruitWizard and Loxo. It asks at internal interview, external interview and placement stages; a five-star placement rating can include a written testimonial for approval, while lower ratings return as follow-up comments. Widgets can show client-only or candidate-only testimonials and can filter by recruiter. Pricing is per user in Australian dollars excluding GST, plus a one-time go-live fee. Best fit: agencies on JobAdder or Loxo wanting stage-based feedback. Limitations: requests only fire when ATS fields are complete and a record has a single recruiter, and video is not described.
Boast: automated email and text asks after placement
Collects video and text through forms and sends requests itself via automated email and text sequences with reminders. Separate forms for clients and candidates, tagging by staff member and location, and one-click approval feed widgets on your site. Plans cap responses and staff seats, so a 10-recruiter firm needs the Team tier; there is no native ATS integration, so placements arrive by upload or Zapier. Best fit: firms that want the ask sent automatically after each placement. Limitation: response caps can bind for high-volume temp desks.
Vocal Video: edited video testimonials, billed yearly
Video-first collector that edits recordings automatically with music, captions and branding. Each audience can have its own collector with up to five questions, recorded from a link or QR code on any device, and finished videos go into embeddable galleries. Billing is yearly only, with no monthly plan. Best fit: firms wanting polished placement stories for site and business development emails. Limitations: written testimonials are not the focus, on-camera consent excludes people keeping a move quiet, and the full year is paid up front.
How to pick
Decide whose reputation you are building. If individual recruiters are the brand, choose a recruiter review tool matched to your ATS. If measured satisfaction and an award matter, a survey programme fits. If owned client and candidate proof on your own site is the goal, testimonial collection software is the right category, and many firms run both a review tool and separate walls. If the gap is Google, Indeed or Glassdoor ratings, that is a reputation suite instead; employee stories for your own hiring are employer-brand work, a different task. Quick checklist before shortlisting: confirm audience separation, milestone triggers, desk-level walls, anonymous credit options, ATS fit, response or seat caps, and total cost at your actual headcount.
| Tool | What goes on your site | A 10-recruiter firm pays | Clients vs candidates |
|---|---|---|---|
| Separate-walls collection tool (owner-confirmed name) | A wall per audience or desk, text and video | See owner inputs | Separate wall and link for each |
| Great Recruiters | Recruiter profiles and review cards | $750/mo on Pro, 10 recruiters included | Reviews tied to each recruiter |
| ClearlyRated | Ratings and testimonials on directory profile | Quote only, billed yearly | Separate client and talent ratings |
| TopRec by Refari | Testimonial widgets | About A$250/mo plus a go-live fee | Client-only or candidate-only widgets |
| Boast | Video and text widgets | $119/mo on Team | A form for each audience |
| Vocal Video | Edited videos in galleries | $99/mo, billed yearly | A video collector for each |
Dated captured pricing evidence; confirm before publication. ClearlyRated is quote-only and billed yearly; TopRec pricing is in Australian dollars excluding GST plus a go-live fee.
Frequently asked questions
How do staffing firms collect candidate testimonials?
Ask at moments when satisfaction is high: accepted offer, first week, and 30, 60 or 90-day check-ins. Send a single link with two or three focused questions and allow text or video replies. A LinkedIn recommendation from a placed candidate can also be added to the candidate wall later.
What should you ask candidates and clients for a testimonial?
For candidates, ask about the search before you and how the new role is going. For clients, ask which role was filled, how long it took, and how the hire is performing now. Those prompts surface concrete detail rather than generic praise.
Is recruiter review software the same as testimonial software?
They solve different jobs. Recruiter review tools rate individual recruiters and build a public record for each person. Testimonial software collects client and candidate stories and displays them on your own website. Many firms use both because the audiences and placements differ.
What if a candidate or client can't be named?
Agree the credit line before publishing. A role plus a type of employer, such as Finance Director at a mid-size logistics company, preserves credibility without naming the person. Some tools let you edit the name and title on each testimonial, and others allow a generic sign-off such as A Client.